That time Ryan Gosling broke up a street fight and a bystander correctly identified him as the guy from The Notebook? That almost never happens, according to Gosling. “They’re disappointed when I’m not Ryan Reynolds,” the actor told E!, acting out a typical conversation with a fan: “‘Oh, can I get my picture with you?’ And you’re like, sure, and they go, ‘I thought you were more muscle-y.’ No. ‘Have you gotten, like, more unattractive for a role?’ No. Just the role of my life.” But he’s gotten used to it. “Sometimes they’ll take a picture with me and then they’ll look at it and I’ll see their faces fall and they realize … that’s not Ryan Reynolds or Paul Bettany or whoever the hell they want their picture with,” said Gosling. Ryan Gosling and the similarly fan-confusing Amy Sedaris should start a club! (No really, we would join.) [E!]